Sirloin vs Ribeye: Which to Order and Why
These are the two cuts most people choose between, and the numbers make the trade unusually clear. An 11oz sirloin is $18.99 and 460 calories. A 12oz ribeye is $22.99 and 960 calories.
One extra ounce of meat, $4 more, and more than double the calories. All of that difference is fat, and whether it is worth it depends on what you want from the plate.
Where the calorie gap comes from
Sirloin runs roughly 42 calories per ounce. Ribeye runs roughly 80. The difference is intramuscular fat — the marbling visible as white threading through the muscle.
That fat is not waste. It renders during cooking, bastes the meat from inside, and carries most of what people describe as "beefy" flavour. Removing it would make the ribeye leaner and also make it taste like something else.
So the calorie gap is not a defect in the ribeye. It is the thing you are buying.
Which is better value
On price per ounce, sirloin wins at every size. The 16oz sirloin is $1.44 per ounce; the 16oz ribeye is $1.75. The 11oz sirloin at $1.73 undercuts even the largest ribeye.
On calories per dollar the gap widens further, though that is a strange metric to optimise unless you are specifically trying to eat lightly.
The fair summary: sirloin is better value, ribeye is better eating, and neither of those statements is controversial.
Which handles cooking better
This is the practical consideration that decides it for many people. Sirloin is lean, which means there is very little margin past medium — cooked to medium-well it goes dry and chewy, and no sauce fully rescues it.
Ribeye is far more forgiving. The rendering fat keeps it moist well past the point where sirloin has given up. If you order steak medium-well or well done, ribeye is the cut that will still be good.
Conversely, if you order rare or medium-rare, sirloin performs well and you save several dollars per ounce for the privilege.
- Order rare or medium-rare → sirloin, and save money
- Order medium-well or well done → ribeye, and accept the cost
- Counting calories → sirloin, by a wide margin
- Want maximum flavour → ribeye, no contest
- Feeding two from one plate → 16oz sirloin
Frequently asked
Is ribeye always more expensive?
Yes, at every comparable size. The cheapest ribeye is $22.99 for 12oz; the cheapest sirloin is $13.49 for 6oz.
Which is more tender?
Ribeye, though neither approaches the filet. Sirloin is firmer and beefier in texture.
Can I get a sirloin with the fat of a ribeye?
No, but the Smother Your Steak option at $2.29 adds mushrooms, onions, jack cheese or brown gravy, which adds richness for far fewer calories than the ribeye upgrade.
Keep reading
The Best Steak at Texas Roadhouse, by Four Different Measures
"Best" depends entirely on what you are optimising for, and the four answers are four different steaks.
Read →
Every Steak Ranked by Price Per Ounce
The number no menu prints, computed for all sixteen steak sizes. It changes which steak looks like the good deal.
Read →
Steak Doneness: What Each Level Actually Gets You
Five levels, and the right one depends as much on which cut you ordered as on personal taste.
Read →